Dear friends of the Wolves,
Please talk to your boys. Tell them about the creepy data company RUSD pays, and the 3,410 checks a year the district buys from it. I believe that mass surveillance explains the 11 investigations we know about. Not their teammates. Not their parents.
A few weeks ago I asked Riverside Unified, under the California Public Records Act, how it decides that a family doesn’t live where they say they live. On November 12 the district sent its answer. I’m publishing all of it. Click the link above to read every document RUSD provided, plus every source for this letter.
RUSD said it “received a complaint with specific information.” I never bought it. A Wolf doesn’t inform on a fellow Wolf. And a dozen players investigated at once? That doesn’t add up.
Now we know that RUSD pays a company to check families in bulk, a whole spreadsheet at a time, using credit bureau data and other consumer data sources. RUSD buys 3,410 of those checks a year. Was your family one of them? I don’t think this started with a parent or a teammate. I think it was a data dragnet, run by the district and CivicBell. Nothing RUSD sent shows how these investigations began, so I’ve asked how a CivicBell result gets used to open one.
Here is what’s in it.
215 investigations so far this year. RUSD opened 104 residency investigations in all of last school year. So far this school year, it has opened 215. The year isn’t half over.
A data company checks families. Since October 2025, RUSD has paid a Bay Area company called CivicBell to check parents’ names and addresses. This year’s contract is $3,751 for 3,410 checks. Staff can check one family at a time, or upload a spreadsheet and check families in bulk. The contract also includes an “Address lookup tool for McKinney-Vento Abuse investigation support.” McKinney-Vento is the federal law that protects homeless students.
Where the data comes from. CivicBell says it checks families against “Authoritative Data Providers,” and it won’t name them publicly, “for efficacy reasons.” Here is what CivicBell’s own website does say it uses: consumer credit bureau data, property records, “verified filings,” phone numbers, and maps of district boundaries. It also offers districts an “investigation Toolkit” to “find people, addresses, and phone numbers.” What else is in the mix, it won’t say. Its contract with RUSD covers checking parents’ phone numbers, and it makes RUSD “solely responsible” for getting “the necessary permissions and consents” to do that. Did RUSD ever ask for yours? I’ve asked the district for the consent language parents see.
Your phone bill doesn’t count. Your phone number does. RUSD’s own proof-of-residency sheet lists telephone and cell phone bills as “NOT Acceptable.” A parent can’t prove where they live with a phone bill. But the district pays a company whose contract covers checking parents’ phone numbers. That’s weird. And, uncool.
What companies like this can see. Because CivicBell won’t name its sources, here is how the industry works. Companies that sell identity and address data build files on nearly every adult from sources like these: the consumer credit bureaus, phone and utility account records, county property and tax records, court records, Postal Service change-of-address data, vehicle registration records where the law allows, and commercial marketing lists. Nobody outside CivicBell knows which of these it buys. Credit bureaus sell the “header” of your credit file, meaning your name, phone, current and past addresses, date of birth and Social Security number, to identity verification companies, and the industry says those sales aren’t covered by the federal credit reporting law. In 2021, Senator Ron Wyden revealed that header data on about 171 million Americans, drawn from phone and utility accounts, had been resold this way through Equifax. And a much bigger competitor, Thomson Reuters CLEAR, sells school districts license plate reader data, records of where cars were photographed, for residency checks. This year a district near Chicago denied a child enrollment after plate reader software showed the family’s car only at Chicago addresses overnight. And in May, the Electronic Frontier Foundation found police searching Flock license plate camera networks for school residency checks, including more than 375 searches by school police in Buford, Georgia, between January 2025 and March 2026. So yeah, using Flock for residency checks is a thing.
What RUSD said, and didn’t say. RUSD says they don’t, and we’ll take them at their word: in October, the district told families it does not “use Flock cameras at any time, for any reason, including as an investigation tool.” But does CivicBell, or someone they contract with? CivicBell has published a post arguing that schools shouldn’t rely on license plate readers, and it won’t say which data providers it uses. Either way, when people raised Flock cameras this fall and RUSD called it “misinformation,” the question wasn’t out of left field. And RUSD’s October statement never mentioned that it pays a data company to check families at all. This is like them saying “oh, that’s misinformation,” but they use a data company to surveil families, and that company keeps its sources secret. So yeah. Thanks, district. When the district says “misinformation,” you probably know you’re on the right track. Who are these people? Oh yeah. They’re anonymous. OK.
Your data, their product. The contract lets CivicBell use what it learns from RUSD families, “during and after” the contract, “to improve and enhance the Services and for other development” in connection with “other Company offerings,” and to share it “in aggregate or other de-identified form.” The contract doesn’t say how a parent can see or correct what CivicBell has on them, what happens if that data is breached, or that it gets deleted when the contract ends. California law requires those protections in contracts with companies that store or manage student records (Education Code 49073.1). I’ve asked RUSD whether it signed one with CivicBell.
“Your child will be withdrawn.” RUSD sent the letter template it uses. It tells a parent: “if we do not hear from you by DATE, your child will be withdrawn from SCHOOL NAME.” It says nothing about a right to appeal. RUSD’s own Board Policy 5111.1 requires a written notice that gives the reason and tells parents they have 10 school days to appeal. It also says a student who is already enrolled “shall be allowed to remain in attendance at his/her school pending the results of the appeal.”
CivicBell advertises RUSD. The RUSD logo is on CivicBell’s homepage. RUSD’s own purchase order terms say a vendor may not release “any advertising mentioning purchaser” without “the express written consent of the District.”
What RUSD didn’t send. How many investigations happened at King, or at any other high school. How many students were removed, how many appealed, and how many won. Anything at all on whether a student stays in class during an appeal. What RUSD has actually paid CivicBell. Any privacy agreement. I’ve asked for all of it by Monday, November 23, and I’ll tell you what comes back.
Keep an eye on RUSD. Other districts already use Thomson Reuters plate data and Flock cameras to check residency. Any day now, RUSD could just go ahead and do the same, if they decide that mass surveilling parents via CivicBell isn’t creepy enough.
What you can do. If you have a child in RUSD, you have the right to see your child’s school records, and California law says the district must let you see them within five business days (Education Code 49069.7). Ask your school in writing whether your family’s information was sent to CivicBell or checked in a residency investigation, and ask for a copy of any results. I wrote the request for you below.
Copy this, fill in the brackets, and send it to your school’s principal or office:
Subject: Request for my child's school records Under Education Code 49069.7 and FERPA, I am asking to inspect and receive copies of all records about my child, [child's name], a student at [school], including any residency verification or residency investigation records, any information about our family sent to or received from CivicBell, and the results of any of those checks. Please provide them within five business days. [Your name], parent of [child's name]
You can also ask the Board to put the CivicBell contract and these investigations on a public agenda.
Go Wolves,
Jim Stewart
King football parent, Bring Back Our Wolves