This week Riverside Unified sent a statement to the MLK community. It’s the first public explanation we’ve seen from the district since three King students were disenrolled on October 2. We’ve posted it in full, word for word, at bringbackourwolves.com/district-update.
Before I respond, I want the district to hear from the people who have spoken up. 430 of you have joined: 124 students, 101 parents, 60 players, 29 alumni, and many more neighbors, staff, and friends. Here’s some of what the players wrote:
“The district shouldn’t take away some of my lifelong friends overnight.”
“The other senior sat out a whole season because of his transfer. They did not deserve this and they did it the right way.”
“They can’t just take away our brothers from us without letting us know or giving any explanation as to why.”
“... being forced to relocate to new schools they don’t have any connections with, when they’ve already spent years at King with no problems.”
“A family shouldn’t be forced to separate.”
And another player wrote to tell us he was removed too, with three games left in his season: “as soon as I got on the bus the district sent us that I couldn’t go.”
Those are the voices in this. Here’s my response.
Some of the statement is welcome. The district says it does not “target” students on legitimate transfers, and that it does not use Flock cameras “at any time, for any reason.” I’m glad to have a clear answer, and I’ll take them at their word. The district also says what we’ve said all along: athletic eligibility is separate from enrollment, and CIF decides eligibility. All three of these boys were on transfers, and all three sat out full CIF seasons to protect their eligibility and their team’s. Enrollment was the district’s decision.
Nobody here is defending anyone who falsifies an address. If a family broke the rules, there’s a process for that. My concern has always been the process.
One complaint, or eleven students? The district says it received “a complaint with specific information.” We’ve heard it was anonymous. Yet we’ve learned of at least 11 students who have been investigated for disenrollment: at least 8 at King, including students who don’t play football, and 3 at Poly. Does one anonymous complaint cover all 11? That would be a remarkable complaint. If it doesn’t, then the statement isn’t telling the whole story. The district says it wants “to clarify misinformation that is currently being circulated.” Why would the district put out misinformation of this magnitude itself?
From everything families are telling us, this looks less like a tip and more like a targeted audit of older, long-approved transfers. If that’s what it is, the district should say so.
And it didn’t start in October. Since at least July, a district investigator from the Pupil Services Department has been knocking on doors and leaving his card, including at the home of a student athlete whose family lives inside the King boundary. Investigations running since summer don’t trace back to one complaint this fall. How many home visits has the district made since July, and at which schools?
End investigations based on anonymous complaints. Anyone can send an anonymous complaint. No one can question it, and no one is accountable for it. Anonymous denunciations have a dark history, and we don’t need that here. I’ve put my name on everything I’ve written, and hundreds of you have added your names too. I’m asking the Board to adopt a policy that an anonymous complaint, by itself, can’t start a residency investigation. Investigations should begin with facts a named person stands behind, which is what “specific, articulable facts” ought to mean.
Publish the process. State law (Education Code 48204.2) says a district that investigates residency must first adopt a policy at a public Board meeting. That policy has to spell out when an investigation may start, which requires “specific, articulable facts,” and what investigative methods the district may use, including whether it hires private investigators. It also requires the district to state the basis for any finding that a student doesn’t live in the district. RUSD’s own Board Policy 5111.1 repeats the “specific, articulable facts” standard. So the district should publish its process: who decides to open an investigation, what facts are required, what methods are used, and what documents families must provide. Publishing a process names no student. Student privacy is no barrier.
How many, and where? The district says it doesn’t target anyone. The easiest way to show that is with numbers. Is every anonymous complaint acted on? How many anonymous complaints about transfers has the district received this school year about students at King, Poly, Ramona, North, and Arlington? How many residency investigations has it opened at each school, and how many began with an anonymous complaint? Totals like that identify no one. If King and Poly are the only schools on that list, we deserve to know why.
Are the students in class? We’re now hearing that the boys are back at school, “awaiting a decision from CIF.” We don’t know exactly what that means, and the district hasn’t said. If they’re back in class, that’s good news, and I’m grateful. But it raises a question. The district’s own statement says eligibility is separate from enrollment, and that CIF decides eligibility. CIF doesn’t decide who gets to sit in a classroom. So why would a student’s place in school wait on CIF? Board Policy 5111.1 already answers this. It gives families 10 school days to appeal, and it says an enrolled student “shall be allowed to remain in attendance” while the appeal is decided. Families tell us they got a notice on a Wednesday and the boys were out by Friday. They should never have been out of class. The district says it wants to minimize “disruptions to student learning.” Then it should confirm publicly that every student under investigation stays in class until the process is finished, and that no student’s schooling is waiting on CIF.
The documents have to make sense. Families tell us the district is rejecting documents that should, by any fair reading, be accepted. We’re hearing of requests no family could meet: a newer version of a document that is still in force and was never meant to be reissued, or a date on a kind of document that doesn’t carry one. I won’t describe any family’s paperwork, because that could identify them. But a request that can’t be met isn’t verification. Every request should make sense: it should show where a family lives today, it should match Board policy and the kinds of proof state law describes (Education Code 48204.1), and it should be something a family can actually provide. Publish the list of documents the district accepts, accept what’s on it, and give families a reasonable amount of time.
What about families whose lives changed? The statement says that if a family moves outside the district, “there are processes in place to request a transfer.” Good. Then a family that moved because of a divorce, a lost job, or a lost lease should be offered that process, not a disenrollment in the middle of senior year.
And remember the timing. On October 1, the day before these disenrollments, the Board voted unanimously to open 900 seats next year to students from other districts. We want students here.
None of these questions are about any one student’s records. They’re about how the district runs a public process under public Board policies.
Put a name on it. It’s telling that the district’s statement carries no name. It’s signed only “Riverside Unified School District.” No superintendent, no trustee, no one who can be asked a follow-up question. That fits a pattern we’ve seen before, from the handling of our cross country and track teams to the one inquiry the Superintendent answered by pointing at another employee: when things get hard, no one at the top puts their name on it. A district that asks families to stand behind every document they hand in should stand behind its own words. Future notices to our community need a name on them. An unsigned statement defending an anonymous complaint is one anonymous voice answering another.
And there is a name. Under Board Policy 5111.1, every step of a residency investigation belongs to “the Superintendent or designee”: writing the procedures, identifying the facts needed to open an investigation, assigning an investigator or hiring a private one, sending the written notice, and deciding the appeal, a decision the policy calls “final.” That makes Superintendent Dr. Sonia Llamas responsible and accountable for these investigations. Who is her designee? Who decided to open them? Our community deserves names, not an unsigned letter.
I’d still like to hear from the people we elected. Dr. Noemi Hernandez Alexander is our trustee and the Board President. Does one anonymous complaint explain 11 investigations? Will she ask the district to publish its investigation process? Will she bring the Board a policy that anonymous complaints alone can’t start an investigation? Does she agree that students should stay in class during an appeal, as Board policy says?
Please email her through the Board office at Emartin@riversideunified.org (ask that your message reach her), and ask her those questions.
Email Dr. Hernandez Alexander →
If you know something about how these investigations are being run, such as documents being refused, families being asked to “re-prove” long-standing transfers, or students outside King and Poly, please write me at jim@bringbackourwolves.com.
Thank you for standing with these boys, and with each other.
Go Wolves,
Jim Stewart
King football parent